A definitive ranking of the Bloody Marys that we’ve tried and written about here, in order from our favorite to least favorite.
- Jacob’s Pickles – Bloody BLT
- Cookshop – Pickled Mary + BLT Mary
- Bespoke Kitchen – Mary’s Walk of Shame
- Sarabeth’s – Pickled Bloody Mary
- ABC Kitchen – abck mary
- The East Pole – Bloody Mary
- Boulud Sud – “Curry Mary”*
- ABC Cocina – Sherry Mary
- Delicatessen – Stacked Mary
- NoMad – Traditional Mary**
- P.J. Clarke’s – Original Clarke’s Bar Bloody Mary
- The Smith – Bloody Mary
- Oyamel – Bloody Maria
- Penelope – Sake Bloody Mary
- Jack’s Wife Freda – Bloody Mary
- The East Pole – Spicy Maria
- NoMad – Sherry Mary**
* I made up this name, because I have no idea what it’s called. Read the post to find out why!
** We tried two Bloody Marys at the NoMad – we loved one and hated the other which is why I’ve listed NoMad here twice.
What should we try next? Would you rank things differently? Leave your suggestions and thoughts below!